How Can One Company’s Experience Pave the Way for Other Companies’ Progress?
When One Company’s Knowledge and Experience Become an Asset for the Entire Holding
Imagine that one company within a large holding has succeeded, after months of effort, investment, and trying different approaches, in resolving a recurring problem in IT service management.
It has improved its support processes, established a clear incident management procedure, and enhanced the quality of services delivered to its users.
A valuable success story.
At the same time, however, five other companies in the same holding are struggling with similar problems.
One is looking for the right software, another is developing its support processes, and a third has hired an external consultant to solve the same issue.
Each is retracing part of a path that the first company has already traveled.
This raises an important question:
Why shouldn’t an experience gained through time, investment, and effort in one company help other companies in the same holding make progress?
This question points to one of the most valuable hidden opportunities in managing large organizations:
turning scattered company experiences into shared organizational knowledge.
One Holding, Dozens of Companies, and Hundreds of Valuable Experiences
Ministries and large holdings usually oversee a group of organizations and companies that have faced various IT challenges over the years.
Some companies have successfully improved their information security.
Others have made their infrastructure more resilient.
Several have reached a good level of maturity in IT service management.
Some have made considerable progress in system integration, business intelligence, or data management.
These experiences are the result of financial investment, specialists’ efforts, testing different solutions, and sometimes overcoming serious crises.
The problem is that many of these achievements remain within the company where they were developed.
IT managers in other companies may not even know that such experience exists.
As a result, an organization that could benefit from its accumulated knowledge and experience may end up paying several times to learn how to solve the same problem.
Within a holding, a successful experience at one company is more than a local achievement; it can become part of the entire group’s knowledge capital.
Why Aren’t Successful Experiences Shared with Other Companies?
At first, it may seem that IT managers from subsidiary companies simply need to hold joint meetings and share their experiences.
These meetings are certainly valuable, but they are usually not enough on their own.
Before transferring an experience, we need to answer several questions:
- Which company performs best in a particular area?
- Is its strong performance the result of an approach that can be transferred?
- Which other companies are facing the same problem?
- Are their conditions and needs similar enough for them to benefit from that experience?
- How can the effectiveness of the transferred solution be assessed?
Without structured information, answering these questions is difficult.
A company may have a successful backup management experience, while the holding may not know which other companies are weak in that area.
Or a company may perform very well in IT service management, but there may be no process for identifying it and presenting its experience for further review.
To transfer experience effectively, we first need to know who has succeeded in which area and who needs that experience.
This is where the role of integrated assessment becomes important.
Assessment: A Way to Discover Hidden Capabilities
When people hear about IT assessment, they often think of identifying weaknesses, risks, and problems.
But a professional assessment is not only a way to find weaknesses.
One of the most valuable outcomes of an assessment is identifying strengths and capabilities that can inspire other organizations as well.
Suppose the IT assessments of 30 companies in a holding show that:
- Five companies perform very well in IT service management.
- Eight companies have serious weaknesses in the same area.
- Three companies have reached a higher level of maturity in information security.
- Several others have made considerable progress in data management and system integration.
At first glance, this information presents a picture of differences among the companies.
For the holding’s management, however, it means something more.
Companies that perform well in a particular area can be considered for learning from their successful experiences.
Companies with weaknesses in that same area may be able to benefit from those experiences.
In this way, assessment can help the holding
connect existing capabilities with the improvement needs of its subsidiary companies.
A higher assessment score alone does not prove that a company has the best practices. Before an experience is presented as a successful practice, its actual results, supporting evidence, and transferability must also be reviewed.
When a Shared Problem Becomes an Opportunity to Collaborate
Suppose an assessment shows that a considerable number of companies in a holding face similar challenges in IT service continuity management.
Some do not have suitable information recovery plans.
Some do not conduct periodic recovery tests.
Others have not properly identified the critical dependencies of their systems.
At the same holding, two companies have achieved a better position by developing appropriate plans, conducting regular tests, and improving their operational processes.
The holding’s management now has two choices.
Option one:
Ask each company to address its problems independently.
Option two:
First review the experience of the stronger companies, identify approaches that can be transferred, and then develop a coordinated improvement plan tailored to each company’s circumstances.
The second option can offer significant benefits, including less duplicated effort, better use of internal expertise, a shorter learning curve, and greater consistency in management and technical practices.
For some issues, it may even be possible to establish shared services or use one company’s specialist capabilities to support others.
This way, a problem initially seen in several companies independently can become an opportunity for collaboration and improved performance across the entire group.
Is the Best-Performing Company Always the Best Model?
There is an important point to consider when sharing experience:
The best performance in one company does not necessarily mean that the same approach is suitable for every company.
Imagine a large manufacturing company with its own data center, a specialized security team, and a complex service management structure.
It may receive a very high score in infrastructure and information security.
But should a small service company implement exactly the same structure?
Of course not.
For a smaller company, shared services, carefully managed outsourcing, or simpler solutions may be more suitable and cost-effective.
Therefore, transferring experience does not mean copying methods.
It means understanding the principles behind success, considering the receiving organization’s circumstances, and adapting the solution to its actual needs.
For example, what can be learned from a company that performs well in service management is not necessarily the name of the software it uses.
The most important lesson may be how it defines responsibilities, measures service quality, analyzes recurring incidents, or builds a culture of accountability to users.
A valuable experience is not simply a method that worked in one company; it is an approach whose underlying logic can be understood and applied where appropriate.
Feedora: Building a Shared View of Companies’ Strengths and Weaknesses
One of the main challenges in transferring experience among companies in a holding is the lack of comparable information.
When each company reports its IT status using a different format, set of indicators, or method, identifying shared strengths and weaknesses becomes difficult.
Feedora addresses this need by providing IT assessments in a consistent and analyzable structure.
The platform assesses companies across seven main areas: governance, information security, infrastructure, service management, information systems, digital transformation, and smart technologies.
Assessment results help holding managers view and compare the status of subsidiary companies across different areas.
This allows the holding to identify which companies are performing better in a particular area, which ones need more attention, and which weaknesses are recurring across several companies.
Comparing assessment results over time can also help identify companies that have made significant progress in a particular area.
These companies may be suitable candidates for reviewing improvement experiences and successful approaches.
By revealing performance patterns across companies, Feedora provides management with information that can help identify opportunities for shared learning.
This does not mean Feedora automatically extracts each company’s best practices or transfers them to other companies. Rather, it provides a structured basis for asking:
“What can we learn from the experience of successful companies, and how can that knowledge help other companies make progress?”
Feedora: From recognizing each company’s capabilities to paving the way for progress across the entire group.